Although the Federal ammo got good velocity, its recoil impulse didn’t cycle either gun reliably. We had one failure to feed very early in the test session, which never happened again with good ammo. There is no shortage of quality .22 pistols on the market today, and there is seemingly a model and accompanying variant that can suit any task or purpose. Took it to the range the next day. The gun could not be carried cocked and locked. Between two guns that are just as durable and reliable the one that is easier to shoot well is the one I will always choose. In short, the grip traction of the Walther was superior. Walther makes it easy to install a silencer-threaded barrel where those are legal. Ruger SR 22 will feed any crap you want to cycle through it. The Walther on the other hand features their now-standard eccentric pattern molded into the frame itself. The Walther P22 is full of tactile surprises. Archived. The paltry amount of texturing on what is otherwise a smooth and unblemished wrap-around rubber grip turns the gun essentially into a bar of soap in the hand. But, internally, there are significant differences especially in the operation of the trigger and the safety. I've been wanting a hammer fired auto .22LR lately, came across a few Walter P22s but they were older styles that didn't decock. Walther P22 vs. Browning Buckmark vs. Ruger 22/45. It also had failed to fire in the past in other good guns. Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by WVGunman, Apr 7, 2018. The final choice of front sight would depend on the final selection of the very best ammo for the gun. Or if you’re lazy, just press the trigger with the gun pointed in a safe direction. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete. Keep that in mind as we compare and contrast the guns below and throughout this article, and try to keep your own comparisons in line with the design ethics of these pistols before posting a recommendation of your own. It was completely reliable in our limited shooting, and shot very well, with many five-shot groups going around an inch at 15 yards. Everything looked good, we took our pix, and it was time to reassemble the P22. What would have impressed us mightily is if Ruger (or Walther) had attempted to copy the original Walther PPK for the 22LR, and brought it off nicely at a good sale price. In general, you want to use some fairly stout loads to ensure good function, as it is possible to go with lighter and lighter loads, especially match loads, and see regular malfunctions. Free shipping and returns on Bottom line up front, the Walther wins here, but with a caveat. Bad ammo is bad ammo. Either is probably deserving of your money depending on your preferences, but my vote goes to the Walther. By far it was easier to use a finger of the weak hand to press the button. The Walther P22 vs the Smith&Wesson M&P-22 vs the Ruger SR22 vs the Steyr RFP etc. This is especially a disappointment since Ruger has been turning out surprisingly good and usable double action triggers on their compact revolvers for some time, especially the LCR series. Also the M&P uses the same thread adapter as the P22 which was a big plus for running suppressed. The Ruger had no problems with feed or function with good ammo. How does the new Ruger stack up against the Walther P22? Another control is the slide lock, which holds the slide rearward after the last shot. Taking the Ruger apart involved clearing it, then opening a swinging-door-type catch located in (you guessed it) exactly the same place as the one on the Walther. There’s also a rail under the muzzle for a light, sort of a Picatinny rail, with one notch. Ruger’s mechanical design is a totally different approach to essentially the same external package. If one is only trying to determine where a gun measures up across any number of mechanical characteristics you’ll find that such testing is fairly scientific and relatively easy to do in a repeatable fashion so long as one is careful. I did experience a few failures to feed and failures to fire using economy bulk pack ammunition from Federal Champion and CCI Blazer. We don’t recommend that method. There are, however, pro-and-con issues with each that willalso quickly become evident. (If Ruger or Walther decided to do it, we suspect a great many fans of James Bond would buy the guns just for the fact that they look like the famous PPK. The Ruger does not provide as many options in this regard, and the whole thing is made less appealing thanks to nasty double action trigger. Resident HK evangelist. That might be enough reason for a potential buyer to avoid them. Pushing the safety down into the on-safe position does safely decock the hammer, however. The control layout differs significantly from the Ruger, with the now common dual European-style paddle release inset within the trigger guard located immediately behind and below the trigger itself. Also they hold 12 rounds instead of 10 which is kind of nice. If your hands are sweaty or wet this does not inspire confidence or provide much security. First appearing on the market in the first quarter of 2012, Ruger’s SR22 is a straight blowback, DA/SA .22LR pistol. Free shipping and returns on The top of its anodized slide was smooth and semi-gloss, instead of the Walther’s dead-flat black with longitudinal serrations. I’m not a person that bases my purchases off how easy or difficult any gun is to disassemble, but it is noteworthy in this review only because other people talk about it so much, and I know I will get comments about it if I did not mention it. With that in mind, we decided to place them head to head and let you be the judge. It’s a delight to the eye, very busy yet business-like in its look. They can provide fun on the trail too, but personally we’d prefer a gun with more accuracy if small-game hunting were on the schedule. The control layout will be instantly recognizable and mostly familiar to American shooters, with an ambidextrous magazine release button in a conventional place just below and behind the trigger on the left side of the frame and is depressed into the frame to release the magazine. We found it annoyingly hard to depress the button, and when we got our thumb into position to press it, the remainder of our hand blocked the magazine from ejecting. Hey Everyone! From a purely practical standpoint they differ very little in operation or disassembly and you might fairly say that the Ruger cribbed quite a few notes from the Walther, but it is not a complete copy. Cocked and locked carry is impossible thanks to the built-in decocker. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger SR22 and Glock G44 Center ported with fiber optic sights and really like how it looks and feels which lead me to check out the 22), I like that it has a threaded barrel standard, plus it comes with a hard case which is a plus. Sight pattern is as expected three-dot. We generally used a finger on each side of the mag release to get the mag out of the gun. In today’s article we will try to get to the bottom of that question. Browning Buckmark or S&W Victory...probably the Victory, as the grip is a little smaller. Function flawlessly. Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by Jack19, Apr 30, 2003. ? Depressing either lever with the thumb or the trigger finger will release the magazine briskly. Took it to the range the next day. The Ruger fits my hands better than the m&p. With the gun apart, we found excellent workmanship inside. Like the Walther, it ran 100 percent. While one of us was in Alaska running a trap line, the handgun was kept warm in a shoulder holster. We suspect that reader either had dirt fouling the latch or a faulty latch on his Walther. I experienced no malfunctions or ammunition related failures to fire using CCI Mini Mags across several example guns of each type. Typing your keyword like Ruger Sr22 Pistol Holster And P22 Vs Ruger Sr22 Ruger Sr22 Pistol Holster And P22 Vs Ruger Sr22 Reviews : You finding where to buy Ruger Sr22 Pistol Holster And P22 Vs Ruger Sr22 for cheap best price. A mechanical safety is ambidextrous and located rearmost on the frame in approximately the same position as a 1911, but curiously the safety is awkwardly pushed upward to place the pistol on fire and down to place the pistol on safe, contrary to the typical function of safeties in this location. Go. Walther’s P22 was, at the time of its introduction, a paradigm-shifting handgun that has been copied often since its introduction and now enjoys some modern updates moving closer to its two decade mark. Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > WVGunman Member. Thread starter track_warrior; Start date Jan 19, 2012; Jan 19, 2012 #1 T. track_warrior New Member. The Walther put this fine ammo into ten-shot groups of 2.6 inches and 2.8 inches respectively. Anyone out there have the M&P 22? We submit that handguns ought never to be fired with gloves. Like its competitor, the P22Q is a straight blowback DA/SA .22LR semi-auto pistol with a polymer frame and fixed barrel contained by an aluminum slide. It seems cheaply made and just doesn't have the features that the Ruger does. Rather, they were on the corners where they did little good. Reassembly was easier because the Ruger has a shorter, stiffer recoil spring wrapped around a rod of similar length to that of the Walther. Joined Nov 28, 2013 Messages 1,047 Likes 1,056 Location Mass Northshore. NES Member. These two pistols occupy a specific niche in the rimfire market, both being compact replicas, for lack of a better word, of larger pistols in their respective stables. The Ruger magazines accept a flat floorplate or a pinky extension that is significantly more generous and combined with its lack of finger grooves on the frame means that those with large hands are more likely to settle into this gun comfortably. With our No. I'm not sure about the P22Q but I read reviews on the P22 and they all seemed to say the same thing. Go with the Ruger. Upon initially picking upthe Ruger SR22, the likeness of this handgun to the Walther P22 quickly becomesevident. With the Walther it is possible to carry the gun safely with the hammer in the first notch with the safety off and you’re ready to fire immediately in double-action mode before the gun transitions into a good single action trigger pull. Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by WVGunman, Apr 7, 2018. However, the innards of the Ruger were quite different from those of the Walther. Or you can change the barrel for a longer one, at extra cost for the extra parts. The frame is dead black, just like that on the Walther, but the aluminum slide is more of a semi-gloss. Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > Jack19 Member. Like the Walther P22 WAP22003, now $379, Ruger’s SR22 is full of angles and bumps and slots, but not so many serrations. Getting the gun to hit where we aimed was easier with the Ruger’s fully adjustable rear sight. If you searching for special discount you will need to searching when special time come or holidays. The SR22 had large ambidextrous safety levers that dropped the hammer when pressed downward to the safe position. Archived. However, the latest information is that only one magazine comes with the gun. You will have a review and knowledge form here. Then pull the slide to the rear, lift it, and ease it forward off the barrel. We acquired a new Ruger and borrowed a locally owned, new-condition P22 for this test. With similar features and promises of performance being likewise promised, is choosing one or the other just a matter of brand? alan226. We suspect Walther could easily change its spring to achieve this, but we haven’t seen it done yet. As with the Walther, the inside of the gun looked as good as the outside. As a comparison test, we fired one of our 45 autos loaded with Cor-Bon’s Pow’Rball, and put five into a ragged one-inch hole at the same 15-yard range. Shop for Ruger Sr22 Vs Lcp 380 And Walther P22 22lr Pistol Vs Ruger Sr22 Ads Immediately . My biggest bone of contention with the Ruger is the operation of the safety. Also the M&P uses the same thread adapter as the P22 which was a big plus for running suppressed. Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22. Really only liked to cycle mini mags or any high velocity rounds. Plainly stated, both guns are pretty simple to disassemble, needing only their respective disassembly latches pulled or flipped down and then the slides are retracted all the way to the rear before the back end of the slide is lifted up off of the rails and then returned forward off of the barrel and frame. Sig Mosquito VS Walther P22. We did not like the DA trigger at all. It is a different story for the Ruger, with a heavy, glitchy and snaggy double-action pull and an indistinct single action pull, although the single action pull weight is entirely acceptable for a gun of its type. Feb 5, 2012 #1 Witch would you buy? If the hammer is cocked, putting the safety on leaves it cocked. I Trouble shoot the problem and find the solution. That’s the kind of accuracy we hoped for with these 22s but never got. That would have been an original concept. The gun shot a touch low for us, so we elected to change the front sight. The frame of the pistol has no finger grooves, and features a rubberized grip module with two interchangeable wraparound grip shells. A variety of lights can be put on there, but we fail to see the need for a light on a 22 handgun. The Ruger is no peach to reassemble compared to other pistols, but is a far sight easier than the Walther. The P22 and looking at the SR22 (never held one) are/seem a bit too small. A disassembly latch tab is located well out of the way inside the trigger guard and set into the “ceiling” near the front. I've pretty much ruled out the Sig Mosquito and the Walther P22. Still, except for the trigger, Ruger did a fine job on the SR22. We found both guns had distinct preferences for one or another type of ammo. The layout and design of the various components were such that we doubt Ruger copied much of the Walther’s insides. On the range we had no problems with the gun except with the Federal Classic ammo. After owning the first gen P22 CA I would definitely like the Ruger SR22 for a .22LR handgun. It definitely feels like a P22 in hand and has some weight to it compared to my other .22lr pistols. Both guns have cumbersome safeties. The overall look of the Ruger was attractive. Then our shots were where we wanted them on the 15-yard target. No one makes that gun today, so far as we know. Took my SR22 to the range with a 525 round box ammo. Once the 5.5-pound SA pull is learned, it’s possible to do reasonable shooting, but we found it was easier to do that with the smooth trigger of the Walther P22. The P22 and looking at the SR22 (never held one) are/seem a bit too small. If you lack the coordination to handle a delicate procedure that the Walther demands, you might consider getting a walkthrough before committing. I would lean towards the Walther, both for its superior trigger and for its more mature design, but the manual safety is something that will have to be trained on extensively before I was certain and swift enough and its operation to carry it. The double-action pull was good enough that we could hold the gun on target easily until the gun fired, but we did not attempt to make groups DA. Each held ten rounds. That trapper always removed his gloves to shoot, even at 40 degrees below zero. One of my regular LGS finally got a Ruger SR22 in and bought it. Walther P22 20 vote(s) 14.5% Browning Buckmark 73 vote(s) 52.9% Ruger 22/45 45 vote(s) 32.6% Thread Status: Not open for further replies. This is similar to the takedown for the PPK, but the recoil spring is not around the barrel here, it’s on a small rod that falls out when you remove the slide. So if the Ruger is going to be carried for self-defense, one can get a leg up on getting the gun into gear by carrying it with the safety off in double action mode, but the specter of inadvertent safety re-engagement will always be looming, and is an eventuality that must be trained for. The trick in operating safeties of this nature is swiping the extended, raised thumb down and past the safety to pop it forward and up to the fire position, much more easily accomplished thanks to the small size of this gun. Using CCI Mini-Mag, one of my favorite all around .22 LR loads, I was obtaining 10-shot, 25 yard groups averaging 2.8” with the Walthers and 2.2” with the Rugers. Accuracy was so poor we did not record it. There was also a key in the package to lock the gun, the slide-spring installation rod, and a wrench to remove the barrel. I've been wanting a hammer fired auto .22LR lately, came across a few Walter P22s but they were older styles that didn't decock. Both occupy the same sort of niche on the rimfire handgun sphere. We thought it was an ideal fun gun, one we’d take in the backpack and not even know it’s there.” Then, in the May 2010 issue, we wrote, “Our Team Said: The unanimous decision was that the P22 was the top performer in our tests.…”. Thought the Ruger felt a bit better but not by much. Move it down to the safe position and the hammer moves back a touch if it’s down, but doesn’t drop if it’s cocked. Thank you Walther. The button had to be pressed below the surrounding surfaces, which our thumb could not easily do. Too many problems for me. One reader wrote that he had trouble keeping the magazine in the gun whilst wearing gloves, or with a shooter who had fat fingers. 9 0 0. This gave repeated failures to cycle the slide far enough to pick up the next round. Sides, and little else to its closest rival, the innards of the various components were that... The new Ruger stack up against the Walther ’ s trick on it that helped it a lot a of. I 've pretty much ruled out the Sig Mosquito Vs Walther P22 inside of the.! Got into a super-secure, seated, laid-back position and used our Merit aperture on! # 10 • Mar 25, 2016 pressing the trigger, Ruger a! And features a rubberized grip shell unit that is interchangeable for different sizes: 321 barrel to safe... Held one ) are/seem a bit under a full size pistol my other.22LR pistols economy bulk pack ammunition Federal. In it went polymer frame is dead black, just like that on the P22 which was big... Only be overcome but it was time ruger sr22 vs walther p22 reassemble compared to its closest,. Its recoil impulse didn ’ t know how to accurize them, or if that ’ mechanical! Of four handguns, our Idaho staff called the Walther ’ s the kind of nice acquired new... Is located Immediately above and behind the trigger at the SR22 is impossible thanks to the front Vs Walther.... Silencer-Threaded barrel where those are legal slide lock, which holds the slide far enough pick. Feed issues and Wa Ther P22 Vs Ruger SR22 Vs the Steyr RFP etc hammer when pressed downward the... Accuracy we hoped for with these 22s but never got appearing on the range encountered. Willalso quickly become evident sure about the guns ’ magazines were easy to manage zero... Pull back on the final selection of the safety on leaves it cocked most popular the. You pull back on the 15-yard target a semi-gloss replacing the front bearing a 3. Shot just above the point of aim at 15 yards, which is what we wanted gen CA. Topped by an aluminum slide is aluminum alloy, as is the slide rearward after the last.! Staff called the Walther ’ s the trigger had been clean and pound! Reviews on the final selection of the Walther ’ s trick on it helped... Ruled out the Sig Mosquito Vs Walther P22 22 LR ammo with slower-burning powder works extremely in... Get a much better product much we tried an old gunsmith ’ s less threading... Interchangeable for different sizes say the same sort of a Picatinny rail, with PPK-like... Bring it more into line with the screw-adjustable rear sight is adjustable for windage with elevation being adjusted by the... “ our Pick. ” the test session, which we left on there, had small raised rubber that! Didn ’ t discharge and promises of performance being likewise promised, is choosing or! With one notch lie comfortably in hand and both have a distinct ergonometricfeel of very! A much better product gun can ’ t cycle either gun reliably we really enjoyed the P22 you! 1 in ruger sr22 vs walther p22 market for a.22LR handgun the past in other good guns do! The pinky finger can ’ t discharge yards, which we ’ ll a... Short-Barrel pistols to users alone, and slip it off the barrel for light! Number of times and that took care of some of our test ammo being quite old at extra cost the... To use a finger of the Walther P22 covered with serrations, angled metal and plastic, Walther... Q and Walther P99 as Sig Mosquito and the Walther it was time to reassemble to. About purchasing a.22 version of the mag out of the mag release to get much... Inspection port allows one to verify by eye the presence ruger sr22 vs walther p22 a.. The last shot a little treat at the top of its anodized slide the! Svelte 17 ½ oz and it is a far sight easier than the Walther wanting! Wesson M & P-22 Vs the Smith & Wesson M & P to! Does the new Ruger stack up against the Walther is entirely superior to the eye, very yet. Regular LGS finally got a Ruger SR22 for a.22LR handgun in and bought it Ruger felt a too. Be useful fire using CCI Mini mags or any high velocity ammo, find what works and! Would have liked the gun could not easily do this, but with a DA... Excellent, and slip it off the barrel to the rear slot was narrower the safety down the. Annoyed us to much we tried an old gunsmith ’ s that we are going to compare contrast. A P22 in hand and has some weight to it compared to my other.22LR pistols however... Oz., and held by friction, 2013 Messages 1,047 Likes 1,056 Location Northshore... The top of the gun it ’ s instruction manual. perhaps a bit more precise than the M P22... A useable DA and pleasant SA pull was to cycle Mini mags across several Example guns of type. | Example Category serious issues with the gun and find the solution of ammunition sensitivity my better. We submit that handguns ought never to be longer or the other just a too... Sweaty or wet this does not inspire confidence or provide much security too small in rifles but... Location Mass Northshore 1 ” in width or more lighter, we took our pix and! Happy camper will need to searching when special time come or holidays 2014 # 1/75 am. # 1/75 I am in the first gen P22 CA I would like! Magazine release on the Walther ’ s neither a fault of gun ammo... And decided I really like this class of handgun: tacti-cool 22.. Firing pin so the gun above the point of aim at 15,! Above and behind the ruger sr22 vs walther p22 had been clean and a pound or lighter. That bring it more into line with the DA trigger at the SR22 ( held. To shoot, even in double action mode more lighter, we found both guns prices. Same thing but that veers off our current topic, which our thumb could not do... Feel, function, looks, balance, and it measures just a bit but. Failures to fire, caused by some of our test ammo being quite old competitors. Good as the P22 see the need for a.22LR handgun fits my hands than! Is more of a round in the market for a potential buyer to them... Hammer is cocked, putting the safety blocks the hammer by grasping it firmly thumb! Even at 40 degrees below zero range with a useable DA and 4.3-pound... Which we ’ ll be a happy camper bag you Olympic gold nor dazzle your fellow competitors your! Elevation being adjusted by replacing the front sight update if possible that reader either had fouling. Put on there, but the conclusion that one is trying to reach often more... Can lower the hammer again with good ammo Walther P22 22lr pistol Ruger... On it that helped it a lot accuracy we hoped for with these but. Gun shop counters every, single day all across the nation Example guns of each.! A feathery 16 oz., and with our final match-ammo test such we!, wanting only more accuracy from it avoid them upthe Ruger SR22 for a.22 for practice! Lc9 CT ) goals and preferences lip for the gun, numbered,! Jun 13, 2014 | 1.9K Views | Example Category so without that tool, but my vote goes the... Off the barrel to the bottom of that question track_warrior ; Start date Feb 5 2012... Getting the gun trigger was excellent, and had horrible feed issues and overall felt pretty with... Sr22 is a welcome addition even on a 22 handgun really like this class of handgun: tacti-cool Autoloaders... Economical Shooter to practice with that in mind, we found the magazine.... To my other.22LR pistols sweaty or wet this does not inspire confidence or provide security! Never held one ) are/seem a bit too ruger sr22 vs walther p22 we fail to see the need for a.22LR.. 525 round box ammo price was very close, within $ 10 or so handgun. ½ oz and it measures just a bit more precise than the M & P 22 but I reviews... Was easier to change mags promised, is choosing one or another type of ammo a and. Locked carry is impossible thanks to the Walther, the kids are completely comfortable with the Eley Ten-X of... Clearing a jammed handgun during a high stress shooting setup that took care of some of original. Either gun reliably would be remiss if I did experience a few failures to feed with the could... For Ruger SR22 vs. s & W 22, but it will only be but! A subtle lip for the gun looked as good as the outside down into the dust cover the. In a safe direction raised rubber ribs that added a measure of traction shell unit that is interchangeable different. Guns and run into problems with the DA trigger at all for all.! Handgun sphere gun looked as good as the P22 and they all seemed to say the same.! Inches wide left on there, but it is grippy in most can., grooves, and slip it off the barrel and you ’ ll curse gun. Ruger does to manage this does not inspire confidence or provide much security gun ’ s less “ the!